The Best Butter Keeper

Best image of butter keepers
Photo: Sweese 3106 Porcelain Butter Keeper Crock - French Butter Dish - No More Hard Butter - Perfect Spreadable Consistency, Turquoise
UPDATED MAY 31, 2020

To help you find the perfect anti vibration glove, we continuously put forth the effort to update and expand our list of recommendable butter keepers. Our team collects, edits and publishes new information, in order to present it to you in an accurate, significant and neatly arranged way.

Best image of butter keepers
Photo: Sweese 3106 Porcelain Butter Keeper Crock - French Butter Dish - No More Hard Butter - Perfect Spreadable Consistency, Turquoise

Our Picks

Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper image
Measures 3.5" / 9cm in diameter and stands 4" / 10cm tall.
Norpro Marble Keeper image
Measures 3.75" / 9.5cm in diameter and stands 4" / 10cm tall.
Norpro Porcelain Keeper image
Measures: 4" x 3.5" x 3.5" / 10cm x 9cm x 9cm. Capacity: 1 stick of butter/ .5C
Our Choice
Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper image
Measures 3.5" / 9cm in diameter and stands 4" / 10cm tall.
Norpro Marble Keeper image
Measures 3.75" / 9.5cm in diameter and stands 4" / 10cm tall.
Low Price
Norpro Porcelain Keeper image
Measures: 4" x 3.5" x 3.5" / 10cm x 9cm x 9cm. Capacity: 1 stick of butter/ .5C

8 Butter Keeper Alternatives

Mrs. Anderson’s Better Butter Keeper stores and keeps butter fresh, soft, and ready for...

Made from natural ceramic earthenware with a scratch-free glaze; sturdy and durable

Bell shape holds butter securely; water in the base connects the butter for an airtight...

3.75 x 3.75 x 5.5 inch

Made of white stoneware, will keep your butter cool, soft and spreadable

Square shape perfectly fits standard butter stick shape, making the setup a breeze

FOR SOFT, SPREADABLE BUTTER. No more hard, crumbling butter that’s impossible to spread.

THREE PIECE FRENCH BUTTER DISH. Fill the middle compartment with water to keep butter a...

KEEPS BUTTER FRESH OUT OF THE FRIDGE. Water creates an airtight seal that prevents spoi...

UPDATED VERSION: BEECH WOODEN LID - Beech is a very hard and tough material. It is also...

TIGHT BEECH LID WITH SILICONE RING SEAL - The top lid helps keep your butter sticks or ...

GENEROUS SIZE: A PERFECT MATCH FOR MOST BUTTER BRANDS - The container measures 6 x 3.5 ...

FEATURES MARKINGS FOR EASY MEASURMENTS: The butter dish features marking on both sides ...

AIR-TIGHT SILICONE SEAL: The innovative designed silicone sealed butter dish is the per...

KEEP YOUR BUTTER IN THE FRIDGE OR COUNTERTOP: This butter dish is able to store your bu...

FRESH AS ALWAYS: No more crumbling with butter every morning! Now it’s time to have a s...

COMPLETELY HANDMADE & MADE IN PAKISTAN: This butter keeper is entirely made of handmade...

HOW TO USE: Fill the lid space with butter & crock with water while keeping it on norma...

SOFT BUTTER AT HAND EVERY SINGLE DAY - This french butter keeper crock is different tha...

A GORGEOUS LITTLE ADDITION TO YOUR KITCHEN - It's the perfect cute shape and looks very...

CUTE AND CLEAN DESIGN - Approximately 4.2" in diameter x 2.0" H. This butter crock with...

FRESH, SOFT BUTTER READY AT HAND AT ALL TIMES - No more cold butter from the fridge! Th...

EASY TO USE, EASY TO WASH - It requires minimal care, and it washes well in the dishwas...

ADEQUATE CAPACITY FOR MOST FAMILIES - The bell holds about 1 and 1/3 stick of soft butt...

Buying Guide

A butter keeper is a crockery container or dish used to keep your butter spreadable soft for up to 30 days. These dishes were originally used to keep fresh butter from spoiling. This was before refrigeration was an everyday item within the home. Although it is not a necessary item any longer, it has regained popularity in recent years. It is nice to have real butter on hand at room temperature when it comes to sautéing or spreading it on toast and other bread items.

Some people say the butter keeper was introduced centuries ago, but those who are authorities on the subject find that the butter keeper came about in the 1800s. They were most likely first used in Brittany or Normandy as these areas were famous for their butter production during that time period. Butter keepers can also be referred to as butter bells, butter dishes, butter crocks, and butter pots.

How a Butter Keeper Works

Understanding how a butter keeper works will help you when it comes time to purchase one. You start by filling the cup attached to the underside of the lid with your butter. Then you fill the jar with water which will create an air tight seal that keeps the butter fresh. Some degree of maintenance is required. It is recommended that you change the water at least once a week. Some people recommend changing it as much as every three days. Salt water can increase the effectiveness of the butter keeper as well.

Butter keepers come in a variety of materials. Some are beneficial while others are simply a matter of personal preference. Stoneware is a popular choice. It gives the look of an antique piece which appeals to those looking for a butter crock. In addition, it is dish washer safe and quite durable. Less expensive designs will be made of ceramic. Ceramic tends to blend nicely with many of the modern dinnerware choices.
Marble serves two purposes. The natural stone will keep the butter cool without the use of refrigeration. It also has a beautiful look to it that is timeless. Marble does need to be hand washed. High-end butter keepers are made out of bone china. This material allows for special finishes such as distressing and embossing.


The size of the butter keeper will determine how much butter can be stored inside of it. You will find some of these dishes will list the capacity in ounces. Ounces would have been the original measurement used due to the fact that butter keepers where invented to keep home churned butter fresh for up to 30 days without the use of refrigeration. In today’s terms, you will find that most modern butter crocks will tell you how many sticks of butter they can hold. The average crock can keep one to one and one half sticks fresh. The average height is four to five inches with a three to four inch diameter.


The shape of a butter dish has nothing to do with how fresh it will keep the butter. It is simply a personal preference. Select one that fits in well with your current dinnerware or the style of your kitchen décor. The butter keeper can be an attractive accent piece when left on the counter top. Basic, inexpensive designs are simple cylinder shapes. Many are made to look like an old fashioned crock. You will also find ones that resemble an apothecary, but not every butter keeper is designed to look like it is one hundred years old. Sleek modern butter dishes often have unique square or rectangular shapes.


If you are new to the idea of a butter keeper and would like an inexpensive one to try, the Norpro Butter Dish Crock Keeper is a nice, inexpensive way to go. This all white ceramic dish holds one stick of butter. It is four inches tall with a diameter of three and one half inches. Its basic design is attractive and functional, but if you want something a little more stylish, the Norpro Glazed Stoneware Butter Keeper is the same size with a pretty blue striping. Both can be found for under $10.

Mid-price butter keepers come in a variety of materials. The unique Norpro Butter Dish Crock Keeper in marble keeps your butter cool naturally, but it does require hand washing. The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain is perfect for those looking for an old-fashioned style. It comes in an antique azure blue, and it has an embossed pattern around the sides. It is constructed of bone china, and it holds one stick of butter within its distressed finish container.

Those who want it all will enjoy the high-end Le Creuset Stoneware Butter Crock in Cherry Red for around $40-$45. The shape has an old fashioned appeal while the bright color makes it blend nicely with the most modern of kitchens. The six ounce design holds one and one half sticks of butter. The non-porous enamel glaze does not absorb odors and resists chipping and staining. It is dishwasher safe, and it includes a lifetime warranty.

Top Rated Butter Keepers

If you're looking into finding the best rated butter keeper, you should probable check out the Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper. We looked at various sources of reviews and found this one to have the best mix between review count and average rating stars.

Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper

The Lowest Price We Could Find

Often, going for the best price is a simple but good option. With a price of $5.93 (last checked this morning), we do not list any other butter keeper cheaper than the Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper. Just remember that it's not always the best option to go for the cheapest one.

The Butter Keeper With the Most Reviews

With at least 1741 reviews and counting, the Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper might be another option to consider. This large amount of reviews signalizes that many people are using it, with most of them beeing satisfied.

High Quality Butter Keepers

It's quite rare that the saying "You get what you pay for" turns out incorrect. If you have the money on the sideline, feel free to choose the most expensive item from our list: The Norpro Marble Keeper currently sells for $21.98.

Norpro Marble Keeper

The Butter Keeper With the Most Clicks

If you trust us and our users, feel free to check out the Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper. Our statistics say that it is the most favorite Butter Keeper from the list above.

Our Bestseller

If you're still undecided, I would recommend that you go with the masses and choose the top selling butter keeper: The Norpro Glazed Stoneware Keeper is the hottest bestseller in this category right now.

Butter Keeper Reviews

There are no reviews on butter keepers, yet.
Be the first to write a review, or check for additional reviews in the Further Reading section below.

Butter Keepers on Instagram

Top Posts for #butterkeeper

Picture by lindermanpottery
I made some of these French butter keeper/bell/crock thing-ies... Thoughts? • • • #butter #potter...
Picture by lucyfagella
These are French butter keepers which I made before the Thanksgiving break. They are out of the k...
Picture by lynessathompson
Happy Thanksgiving everyone!! I am so happy with how this glaze turned out. I think it's one of m...
Picture by shawnapiercepottery
My butter keepers will be taking on a new look. I have been thinking about this direction for som...

New Posts for #butterkeeper

Picture by pitcherpottery
Just completed some butter keepers. Next stop, bisque fire. If your...
Picture by backhausbread
Breakfast. Thanks, team! 🙌🏻
Picture by attic.antics
A year ago, the company I worked for had a gorgeous plant arrangeme...
Picture by sylerstudiopottery
just 3 of the many butter keepers i cranked out this holiday season...

Further Reading on Butter Keepers

New: Our editorial list of additional articles. We decided to gather informartion all around the internet and present you a list of helpful, external links to interesting reads about reviews, pros & cons and similar products.
Has anyone used a Butter-Bell? - GardenWeb
This one you put cold water in the base and invert the butter dish part into the water. What are your pros and cons if any of you have them?Videos4:43Best Butter Keeper Reviews 2017 – How to Choose the Best Butter TopProducts.comYouTube... ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or not helpful
10 Butter Keepers and Crocks | Kitchn
Some say butter keepers or crocks are the secret to soft, spreadable butter. Ever since Melissa Clark raved about her marble butter keeper, I've  ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or not helpful
Official Butter Bell® Store - Original ButterBell Crock
The Original Butter Bell® Crock by L. Tremain A modern version of the the L. Tremain company has popularized this natural method of preserving the creamy   ‎Butter Bell Crock Help & FAQs - ‎View All Butter Bells - ‎Antique Collecti... ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or not helpful
Here's the true secret to easily spreadable butt...
I've tried the Butter Bell (two versions seen in the top row of images) and the Butter Boat. butter keepers at Amazon by searching for Butter Boat or Butter Bell. . The butter boat, though, could be an interesting alternative. ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or not helpful
Le Creuset Stoneware Butter Crock | Williams Sonoma
Fill the crock with cold water to keep butter soft and spreadable–without refrigeration–for 3 to 5 days. Change the . Cons: limited colors. ✓ Yes . + Pros: Durable,: Texture,: Quality,: Easy to Clean,: Color,: Easy to Store,: Size,: Desi... ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or not helpful
Butter Crock | Le Creuset® Official Site
Butter crocks have been in use in parts of Europe dating back to the Middle Ages, long before reliable refrigeration was available. These airtight ceramic vessels  ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or not helpful


Do you want to know more about butter keepers? Check out the links below to gain knowledge about the whole topic of butter keeper products.


Comments on this page are currently disabled.

About this Article

This page about Butter Keeper was composed by and published by
It was last updated on and has been viewed 929 times.

Did you like this article about Butter Keeper? Please rate it!

3 out of 4 people liked this article. This is equivalent to a star rating of 3.75 / 5.

Vote Now:

Like or Dislike
Copyright Notice: Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of, Inc. or its affiliates.